Penalty missed:

Valencia CF: Cillessen – T. Correia, Paulista, Guillamón, Gayá (C) – Wass (80. M. Vallejo), Račić (80. Ch. Oliva), Soler, A. Blanco (66. Guedes) – Gómez (90+3. Lato), Lee Kang-in (66. Gameiro).
Subs: Rivero, Doménech – Cutrone, Ferro, Gameiro, Guedes, Lato, Mangala, Ch. Oliva, Jason, M. Vallejo, Musah.
Coach:

Villarreal CF: Asenjo – Foyth, Albiol (C), P. Torres, Estupiñán (46. Trigueros) – Chukwueze, Capoue (72. J. Costa), Parejo, Moisés Gómez (88. Bacca) – G. Moreno, Alcácer (46. Pedraza).
Subs: Rulli – Bacca, Baena, J. Costa, Ra. Funes Mori, Niño, Pedraza, Raba, Trigueros, M. Gaspar.
Coach:

Referees: Estrada – Alonso, Porras

Attendance:

Penalty missed:

Schalke 04: Rönnow – Becker, Mustafi, Thiaw – William, Serdar, Bozdogan (46. Stambouli), Kolašinac (78. Mascarell), Calhanoglu – Hoppe (61. Schuler), Raman (90+3. Oczipka).
Subs: Langer – Mascarell, Mercan, Oczipka, Schöpf, Schuler, Stambouli, Flick.
Coach:

1. FSV Mohuč 05: Zentner – St. Juste, Bell, Niakhaté, D. da Costa (81. Brosinski), Kohr – Barreiro (89. Stöger), Latza (46. Boëtius), Mwene – Ádám Szalai (75. Glatzel), Burkardt (88. Quaison).
Subs: Dahmen – Boëtius, Brosinski, Glatzel, Hack, Kunde Malong, Öztunali, Quaison, Stöger.
Coach:

Referees: F. Brych (Německo)

Attendance: